Will the Real Andy Sachs Please Stand Up? Former Assistants Gathered at Replica Handbag Store Book Club’s Latest Meetup

“There would be no Devil Wears Prada without you,” Chloe Malle told a room at Metrograph that looked, for one night, as though the Vogue masthead of the last three decades had stepped off the page and taken their seats together in a movie theater. For the second Vogue Book Club gathering—this one devoted to Lauren Weisberger’s The Devil Wears Prada and paired with an advance screening of its long-awaited sequel—Malle had cleverly invited a particularly knowing audience: more than twenty of Anna Wintour’s former assistants, the “real Andy Sachses,” alongside designers, editors, and readers, many of them veterans of the very world Weisberger fictionalized.
What unfolded felt part book party, part oral history, part reunion. Wintour only ever had three assistants at a time, making the sight of so many former baton-holders in one room unusually rare. And what a room. Vera Wang, in an oversized gray blazer and red-tinted glasses—herself once an AW assistant—mingled with Caroline Palmer, whose Workhorse offers a rather un-veiled account of her own years at Vogue; Indre Rockefeller, Claiborne Swanson Frank, Cynthia Smith, and other alumni embraced with the warmth of people who had survived a shared institution.
Cocktails began at five across Metrograph’s two floors amid lush flowers, trays of sliders and hors d’oeuvres, and a full bar whose cocktail and mocktail menu was laced with Devil Wears Prada jokes—including a spirit-free concoction dubbed the Devil Wears Nada. With thanks to Samsung Galaxy and support from Tiffany & Co., the evening carried no shortage of thoughtful flourishes: popcorn came in trompe l’oeil cartons disguised as the novel’s cover, while guests stepped into the Samsung Photo Activation with Samsung Galaxy, posing with placards riffing on favorite lines (“Everybody Wants to Be Us” among them), though former assistant Carolina Gonzalez used the occasion to make the reunion feel even more like one, proudly scrawling her own: “AW assistant class of 2020–2023.”
There were designers in the mix too. Tanner Fletcher’s Tanner Richie and Fletcher Kassel were discussing Met plans involving no shortage of handcraft, while Richie confessed, to great amusement, “Oh, I was nine when the movie came out”—a remark that landed especially well in a room full of people who had, in one form or another, lived it. Nearby, Batsheva Hay lifted a copy from a display of Weisberger novels, laughing, “I don’t know if these are giveaways, but it’s for my daughter!”—and just like that, another generation is introduced to Miranda Priestly.
And naturally, the designers turned out too: Domenico Dolce, whose house occupies a memorable place in both the original film and the sequel, mingled with Prabal Gurung, while Grace Coddington and Tonne Goodman held court nearby; Soull and Dynasty Ogun were among those in the mix as well. It was a reminder that the glamorous cast orbiting Runway on the page was never all that far from the real thing.
Then came the evening’s central tease: an advance screening of The Devil Wears Prada 2—strictly no spoilers, gird your loins for its opening next week. And when the credits rolled, guests stayed planted in their seats for a post-screening conversation, recorded live for Vogue’s The Run-Through podcast, with two particularly beloved Vogue alumni: William a.k.a Billy Norwich, the longtime writer and editor now overseeing fashion and interior design at Phaidon Press, and celebrity stylist Kate Young—once Anna Wintour’s assistant, now the force behind the red-carpet wardrobes of Dakota Johnson, Scarlett Johansson, and Rose Byrne. The conversation proved nearly as entertaining as the film itself.
Asked what she made of the film’s characterization of her former life, Young, reassessing Andy Sachs with prosecutorial rigor, announced: “She’s a terrible assistant. She should have got fired,” before adding, to cheers, that Andy’s boyfriend was “the worst.” She admitted she had loved even the tasks the book cast as drudgery. “I liked that she put her dry cleaning and coat on my desk,” she said. “I opened the closet and unzipped it and thought—wow, cool. I had never seen couture before.” Seeing the film in 2006 unsettled her so much she “called my therapist,” wondering, “Am I a masochist?! I loved this job.”
Her recollectsion of the book’s first arrival in the office was even better: Lisa Love passing around galleys through interoffice mail, assistants sneaking them down to the Four Times Square (then Vogue HQ) loading dock to read aloud between cigarettes. “It was horrible,” Young laughed of recognizing the satire. “She was making fun of us.” But what, she seemed to suggest, was worth making fun of was also what made the place thrilling. “Everyone worked so hard. Everyone was so smart…they could talk about shoes for a day.” It was, she said, the first time she thought, “I’m not a freak. I love these people.”
Norwich, meanwhile, revived one of Vogue lore’s great artifacts: the legendary hundred-question culture test he once devised to weed out aspiring assistants who, as he put it, “never read Vogue.” As he explained, he and Charles Gandee built the exam from a hundred figures who formed Vogue’s “constant cast of characters”—“if they wrote a book, if they coughed, if they made a frock, they got covered in Vogue.” Recently resurrected by The New York Times and gone viral anew, the quiz seemed almost a secret handshake for many in the audience.
Then Malle unearthed an old piece of career advice from Kate, who once said aspiring stylists should “max out your credit card and start smoking.” Asked whether it still held up, Young laughed that perhaps not.
Perhaps not. But it was a fitting final note for an evening spent revisiting the legends people tell about work, style, and ambition.

































